Policy and Intelligence | Charles Duelfer

Policy and Intelligence

There has always been a debate about the relationship between the Intelligence Community and the Policy leadership.  The idea was that those charged with intelligence should stick to intelligence collection and assessments.  For the past few weeks, one of the most vocal spokespersons for the Administration’s foreign policy has been John Brennan.  He as given presentations at the Harvard Belfer Center and a long interview with Charlie Rose at the Council for Foreign Relations in New York.  He discussed all sorts of matters related to international security policy and the status of the Administrations efforts around the globe.  Probably one of the best spokespersons for the Administrations efforts.

But is that the job of the director of CIA?  At not time did he say, sorry, your question relates to policy matters and I can only address the subject from the standpoint of the intelligence community.   Nor, did anyone ask him if he wasn’t straying outside his lane.  His presentations are well done, but in another administration, criticism was piled upon intelligence officials who were seen to be supporting a policy view rather than sticking strictly to the business of making assessments of intelligence.

It will be interesting to see if it is Brennan or DNI Director Clapper who makes the case about whether Iran’s nuclear program can be monitored and whether we will have sufficient confident warning that they are breaking out.


This entry was posted in Intelligence, Iran, WMD. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Policy and Intelligence

  1. Serre says:

    Good morning Mr Duelfer,

    I am a French film maker and I would like to reach you in order to speak about your experience in Chad in the 80′.
    I am preparing a 52 minutes historical documentary on Hissène Habré which will be broadcast on France 5, one of the public channel in France and on several european channels and Al Jazzera (english).
    As you certainly know, Hissène Habré is going to be judged for Humanity crime in the end of june in Dakar. I am going to interview several politicians, military men… who where in Chad in this time. I would like to interview you.

    Can you send me your phone contact or e-mail in order I can tell you more about my documentary ?

    Best regards

    Magali Serre

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free